Email Marketing & List Building for Makers

Disclosure: some of the links below are affiliate links, meaning, at no additional cost to you, I will earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase.


Ok my friend: it’s time to think about getting back “out there” in the world, which means (maybe) getting back into craft markets, art fairs, and shows.

Yipee yahoo!


As you get ready to do this, you will be busy in your crafty space, happily making your beautiful goodies and getting excited to get some cash flow (because...who doesn’t love cash flow?!). 


I am going to challenge you, though, to make a little bit of a mindset shift on how you look at shows.


Ok, this might be kind of a HUGE mindset shift...but hear me out.


I have been in ‘the biz’ of selling at markets since 2010. Sometime around 2017, I started to shift my mindset from “going to this show to make money is my #1 priority” to “going to this show to get new customers on my email list is my #1 priority” (although making money was a very very very close second!). 


Yup, I just said list building, not selling, is my #1 priority at a market.


Now if this made you recoil in horror, don’t click away just yet. This makes sense, I promise.

At my biggest event of the year, I would walk away with a nice big pile of cash (5 digits worth) and would be excited to come back again the following year. The people who bought from me all got my business card, and every now and again some of them would buy from me online, but I really didn’t have that huge money-making opportunity again for another year, when it was time for that event again.

Then I started to think,


 “...what would I do if this show didn’t happen anymore (see: 2020)? This is a lot of money, and boy, would I miss it…not to mention, I LOVE my show customers. I want to be in contact with them all year long, not just at these events!

See, for all those years at shows, I had been telling everyone and anyone “like me on Facebook!” and “follow me on Instagram!”, but I almost never said “join my email list!”.



Yes my Facebook following grew, and my Instagram following grew, but I was really just shifting my “problem” over into another platform...what would I do if social media went away tomorrow?

That’s when I realized that I needed to make sure I was really connecting with my audience in a way that would allow me to reach out to them at any time, without relying on other businesses (like shows or social media) to give me an venue to do so. By not focusing on my email marketing strategy, I was LITERALLY leaving money on the table. 

Like me on Facebook!” became “join my VIP list!”.

I realized that my beloved show customers were actually EXCITED to be on my list...they loved to hear from me as much as I loved to hear from them. With each passing event, more people joined the list, and more people became engaged with the online side of my business.

Now, instead of relying on going to craft fairs and markets to sell, I am able to nurture my amazing customers through my email list, which keeps them coming to my website (and buying!) on a regular basis.

THIS is why my #1 priority at shows is list building, NOT selling, and why it should be your #1 priority as well. Long story short: email marketing works!


If the last 12 months has taught us anything, it’s that you simply cannot rely on someone else (i.e, a show promoter or event) to give you a place to are setting your business up for a catastrophic failure if that’s your only means of making money. 

This is a glaring spotlight on my point, which is that having an engaged and expanding email list is a non-negotiable in your business (again, see: 2020 if you want to remember what it’s like to rely solely on shows for the majority of your sales). Email marketing should be your #1 priority in your marketing efforts if you want more visitors to your website and more sales. 

Now let's talk about what this means for you, 

and how the heck you can get your email list started 


Step #1: Get scrappy


I’m gonna let you in on a little secret here: you *probably* have an email list already, even if you don’t know it.


Say whaaaaat?!


  • Dig through your email inbox/folders
  • Gather up those notebook pages
  • Pull out the collection of business cards

Look at all of those people you’ve connected with! Now, you can’t just add them to your marketing list (your email list that you’re going to send sales emails to), but you CAN reach out to them individually and ask if they’d like to be on your list.

Step #2: Get an Email Service Provider

Pro tip: you can’t send marketing emails from your private email account, meaning that you can’t just open up Gmail and start sending.

An Email Service Provider (ESP) is a service that allows you to send business-related emails to a subscriber list. This is where you are going to gather subscriber information and how you are going to send out your regular newsletters. 

If you are new to this, you can grab this free email service provider guide for some insight on how to choose one and where to start. 

Step #3: Invite people to join

If you are at a market or show, you want to make sure that everyone who steps foot in your space gets an invitation to be on your VIP list. I don’t mean that you put some sad little notebook out and hope that people write down their info: I mean that you actually, out loud, INVITE people to join. 100% of people who buy something from you should hear something along the lines of,  “would you like to join my VIP list? You’ll get updates on new product launches and when other shows like this pop up in your area!

This step also means having a way to collect their information, which can be as simple as a notepad or as high tech as a device where they can enter in their name & email.


List building isn’t limited to just your in-person shows. You want to be making the most of your online presence to get your followers to become subscribers by giving them frequent, simple opportunities to sign up.


Things you can do to get people onto your email list include:

  • Get a signup form on your website
  • Use the “landing page” feature in your Email Service Provider to create a link just to your signup (then post that link in ALL of your Etsy listings, on your website & on your socials!)
  • Consider creating a freebie to build up that list (a guide, a discount, a printable, etc). 


Once you get people to sign up for your email list, your next job is to make sure you are nurturing that relationship by emailing them regularly with value-packed content (when someone joins your email list and then they never hear from you, it feels like giving your phone number to a cutie and then ever hearing from them...WHY ASK IF YOU AREN’T GOING TO CALL?!).



A warm, engaged, growing email list is going to be the lifeblood of your business. As we move into this new phase of life, I am inviting you to make the necessary mindset shift and get into full-time ‘list building mode’ at your shows this year. I promise you: the results are worth it!




50% Complete

Two Step

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua.